[ Home ]
[ Up ]
[ Info ]
[ Mail ]
Cause of Character Traits --- According to
Aristotle
What makes for an unjust person? What causes the character
trait of "unjustness"? According to Aristotle this character
trait is caused by a person repeatedly doing unjust acts.
What causes the character trait of profligacy? According to
Aristotle this character trait is caused by a person spending
his time in drinking, etc..
What causes the personality trait of carelessness? According
to Aristotle people acquire this character trait through
leading disorderly lives.
According to Aristotle: "Activity in a certain thing gives a
man that character --- dispositions are attained through
actually doing things." (Ethics, Book III; The Philosophy of
Aristotle, p.324)
Also, according to Aristotle, a man who has become unjust or
profligate or careless, cannot stop being so just by wanting to
stop. Just as a man who is ill cannot become healthy just by
wanting to. The unjust or profligate or careless got that way
through actions taken of their free choice but once they have
become that way it is not possible for them to be otherwise.
The following excerpt comes from Aristotle's Ethics, Book III
(see The Philosophy of Aristotle, p. 324, 325):
"But perhaps the man's character is such that he cannot take
care. Well, people themselves are responsible for getting like
that, through living disorderly lives: they are responsible
for being unjust or profligate, the former through evildoing,
the latter through spending their time drinking, and so on.
Activity in a certain thing gives a man that character; this
is clear from those who are practicing for any contest or
action, since that is what they spend their time doing. Not
knowing that dispositions are attained through actually doing
things is the sign of a complete ignoramus.
Also, it is absurd to say that the man who acts unjustly does
not wish to be unjust (or profligate, when it is a case of his
doing profligate acts). If a man does acts, not in ignorance,
that will make him unjust, he will be voluntarily unjust.
However, he will not stop being unjust and become just merely
by wanting to. Nor does a sick man suddenly become healthy.
It may happen that his illness is voluntary because his way of
life is unrestrained and he disobeys his doctors. At the
start, it was possible for him not to be ill; but this is no
longer so, once he has let things go. It is like the man who
has let the stone go and cannot recover it. However, letting
it go was in his power, since the principle of action was in
him. Similarly with the unjust and the profligate: at the
start it was possible for them not to become like that; that
is why they are voluntarily so. Once they have become that,
however, it is impossible for them not to be so."
In other words, according to Aristotle, character traits such
as unjustness, profligacy, carelessness, etc. are just habits
(they are not inherited). They are formed (as all habits are
formed) by actions, which being often repeated, become fixed
personality patterns. There is a proverb that says something
like "Habits begin as threads and end as cables". Bad habits
enslave people and that is what happens with unjustness,
profligacy, carelessness, etc.. The characters of most people
are formed when they are children. The habits they acquire
when they are in the process of growing up are those that
determine their life-long character. One's character and
personality is pretty much "set" in his younger years by the
choices he made as a child (my view).
[ Home ]
[ Up ]
[ Info ]
[ Mail ]