[ I | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | lyr ]
INTRODUCTION
In the
summer of 2005, I decided to hop on the bandwagon and read Harry
Potter and the Half-Blood Prince.
This declaration wouldn't mean much in itself, as millions of
other
people were doing the same thing at the time, as the book was one of
the big
literary hits of the year, the sixth in an already popular series of
novels. But my experience was a bit
different for a few reasons.
First
of all, I'm not a fan of Harry [expletive deleted] Potter.
I think it's fair to say that I hate his miserable guts. The popularity of these books has annoyed me
for years, and you're welcome to accuse me of being jealous, ignorant,
contrary
for its own sake, or whatever else you like.
The point is still the same. No
sir, I don't like it.
(Of course,
this hasn't stopped me from participating in Artifice, a
fanfiction role playing game set in an alternate world based on the
Harry
Potter books. This is because I thought
it would make an interesting challenge, and the other players are very
sharp
writers themselves and enjoyable to work with, and premise of Artifice
uses only the background of the
Harry Potter mythos. In a nutshell,
Voldemort won World War II. I like to
think that Harry Potter is lying dead in a shallow grave somewhere
while I play
around with his toys. So part of my
reasoning for reading one of the books was to get a feel for the
"rules" as it were. It's one
thing to know that my character could learn to teleport himself, but it
adds an
extra dimension to my writing when I know that the teleportation causes
a
sensation of intense pressure, like being squeezed through a rubber
hose. So if nothing else, the book helped
me work
out a few hitches. But I digress.)
The
second distinction is that I decided to log my reading experience in my
blog,
figuring that my more-or-less-real-time reactions to each chapter would
make an
amusing reading experience for anyone who was interested.
Again, Artifice sort
of
inspired this decision, as I wanted to keep a record of my impressions
and
questions so that I could refer back to them later if I forgot
something. Also, I just think it's funny
when I rant
and rave over something trivial. Again,
none of this is unique in itself, as I'm sure many people have analyzed
a Harry
Potter book in great detail on the internet, but I thought that the
views of an
anti-fan might make an interesting counter to all of that.
One of the things I hate about the Harry
Potter franchise is how shamelessly the media covers it, heaping
accolade after
accolade over it as though it were the greatest artistic achievement in
the
history of fiction. So for once, I
decided, there could be a more or less impartial view of a Harry Potter
novel,
provided I read it with an open mind and gave it a fair chance.
The
third difference here was, of course, that I was starting with the
latest book
in the series. Harry Potter was
intended to be a seven-book set, and HBP is the penultimate volume. More than a few die-hard Potter fans
insisted to me that I was making a mistake in doing this, and that I
should
have picked an earlier, or at least better, book to start on. This is, of course, ridiculous, as I hate
Harry Potter and it should be more than enough that I would consent to
read ANY
of his lousy books. I didn't pick Book
Six because I thought it was the best or most accessible book for a new
fan. Rather, I picked it because it
would have the most current information I'd need for my RPG, because it
would
make the most topical subject for my blog, and because Wal-Mart was
selling it
for half-price.
Ultimately,
I didn't care much for the book, and found new reasons to hate Harry's
guts,
but I like to think I learned a few things along the way.
For one thing, Harry Potter fans? They
seem to be pretty good sports about the
whole thing. I don't think
"Serenity" fans would care much for me calling River Tam a Super
Dumbass, and I'm pretty sure "Animaniacs" fans wouldn't take kindly
to the suggestion that Wakko is only tolerable when reimagined as a
giant
insane robot. For all their bluster,
groups like Fandom_Wank get pretty touchy whenever you offer insightful
critique like "You Suck", but HP fans seem to let it slide, or at least
the ones I've encountered. I think this is because, deep down,
they hate these characters as much as I do, but just don't feel like
turning against the books entirely. So yeah, they're all
right.
All right, so enough
filibustering, let's meet some of the main plaers
in this sprawling, modern day epic.
OUR
CAST OF CHARACTERS
![]() |
Harry
Potter aka "The Boy Who Lived" aka "The Chosen One" aka "Booger Red"
aka "Mr. Wrestling II" aka "Crap Boy" aka "The Rowling Family College
Fund" The main character, although this is never truly justified. Years ago, he was prophesied to become the "Chosen One" who would rise up to challenge the evil Lord Voldemort and his Death Eaters, although I should point out that said prophet was hammered at the time. Nevertheless, this didn't stop Voldemort from trying to kill him when he was a baby, only to end up orphaning him instead. Despite being the last best hope for the forces of good, he mostly hangs in the background and watches more competent characters move the story along for him. When trouble brews, he tends to jump to conclusions, whine about percieved injustices, and angrily defer to authority figures. Count on him to choke when anyone is depending on him. Harry
possesses
numerous powers and skills, thanks to his training as a wizard and the
harsh life of a fictional British orphan. For example, he can lie
very still while stronger characters fight in his place. Also,
when a problem is too difficult or complicated, he simply ignores it
and approaches a less important problem instead, until someone else
provides him with a solution. The distinctive scars on his
forehead and hands are a testament to how easily Harry's enemies can
carve doodles and crib notes into his flesh. Often seen
with
longtime friends Ron and Hermione, a group which has been unofficially
been termed "The Trio." I prefer to call them "the nWo", but then
again, I call everything "the nWo". Fun Fact: Ironically, all the personality traits that supposedly make Harry a better hero in his books are the same flaws that turn Anakin Skywalker into a tragic villain in Star Wars. Deep, huh? |
|
Ron
Weasley Fun Fact: While the rest of the characters are at least superficially focuses on national security and academic success, Ron's interests remain fixed entirely on moving out of his parents' place and making out 24-7. This makes him either the dumbest guy in the story or the smartest, depending on how you look at it. |
|
|
Hermione Granger The smart girl in class, although
this isn't a tough
reputation to maintain when you spend all your time with two idiots
like Harry and Ron. Fights with Ron all
through the book, only
to end up going steady with him by the end, but I think this had more
to do
with sympathy than attraction. Will
research anything at the drop of a hat, although her legwork never
seems to
accomplish anything useful. Unlike your
typical HP wizards, who inherit their powers from one or both parents,
Hermione is the offspring of two mild-mannered dentists. This is
how you can tell the books are works of fantasy, because everyone knows
that there is no such thing as a British dentist. Fun Fact: It's only half past twelve, but I don't care; it's five o'clock somewhere. |
|
Ginny
Weasley
Ginny's
sort of a supporting character, as she
only seems to show up just long enough to emasculate Ron, participate
in sporting events, and create sexual tension for Harry. Fun Fact: An image search for Ginny on Google turns up a lot of crap, so I just went with this scan from Amazing Spider-Man #42. Rowling apparently didn't think you'd notice the difference, so I don't see why I should give you any more credit. |
|
|
Draco
Malfoy
Fun Fact: Despite cramming dozens of annoying characters into the series, Rowling apparently felt we needed a spoiled, self-important brat on top of everything else. This is how you know she hates me. |
| Albus
Percival Wulfric Brian Kennedy Emilio Rainflower Skywalker Baba Booey
Levesque Cambridge Rodriguez Montgomery Dumbledore
The headmaster of
Hogwarts, which is the magic school where Harry attends classes to
become a
fully
accredited wizard or whatever. Being
that "Albus Dumbledore" takes for-freaking-ever to type, I prefer to
call him "Big Al" or "D-dore" for short, so be
advised. As is the case with all
manipulative, grandfatherly authority figures in pop literature,
everyone assumes
that Dumbledore has some master plan to save the day, yet at the same
time no trusts
the old
man's judgement. Whether or not he
actually has a plan is never
made clear by the end of the
book, which leads me to believe he's just making it up as he goes. Basically a laid-back, patronizing version
of Gandalf the White, or a more senile version of Professor
X. Fun Fact: Snape kills him on page 596. Well, I thought it was fun. |
|
|
Severus
Snape The titular Half-Blood Prince, who kills Dumbledore and is revealed to have been the one who informed Voldemort of the "Chosen One" prophecy, which eventually led to the murder of Harry's parents. You'd think all these startling revelations would make him a more compelling character, but somehow he manages to avoid this. He's either gay for Remus Lupin, or he used to have a thing for Harry's mom, depending on who you ask. I prefer to think Remus is Harry's mother, which settles a lot of issues at once. Despite his allegiance to the
Death Eaters, Dumbledore trusts Snape implicity, and so to keep anyone
from being sure just where his loyalties lie, Snape has been depicted
as a very morally ambivalent character. This means Chicks Dig
Snape. Hot chicks, too. If you're having trouble with
women, chances are it's because you don't fully appreciate the
intricate complexities of Snape's character. And if you're a
heterosexual male, chances are you're perfectly happy with that. Fun Fact: Snape's last known contact with shampoo took place in 1972. |
| Horace
Slughorn The new character, sort of like
how Lando Calrissian
was
introduced in the second Star Wars movie. Only,
you know, not cool. Dumbledore recruits
Slughorn out of retirement to fill an
open
slot in
the Hogwarts faculty, but he has an ulterior motive in mind. Dumbledore has an ulterior motive, I mean. Slughorn's
as transparent as a windshield, so his only ulterior motive is to buy
candy under the pretense of giving it to other people for Christmas. Besides delicious
ham, Slughorn's main weakness is his fascination with celebrity.
Were he an American, he'd probably settle for calling in to the Howard
Stern show every five minutes, but as it is he prefers to hobknob with
certain students in the hopes that they'll become famous later in life
and invite him to parties and stuff. This is how you can tell
it's a 600+ page book, because there's actually room for a dull premise
like this. Since he's the new guy, Horace is just about the only Harry Potter character who doesn't have a hundred crappy anime-esque fan art images polluting Google, so I went with this picture of 27th President and 10th Chief Justice of the United States, William Howard Taft. Fun Fact: Slughorn is very fat. |
![]() |
![]() |
Tom
Riddle, Jr., aka "Lord Voldemort" aka "Tom D. L. Rodlover"
The bad guy of the series. While
he never actually appears in the main
story, much of the book is dedicated to his origin, which is actually a
very
compelling analysis of his psyche. A
narcissistic sociopath obsessed with immortality, Riddle appointed
himself "Lord
Voldemort", a nom de guerre based on an anagram of his full name. Yes,
it's as retarded as it sounds. I
liked it better when Sergio Agrogenes did it in 1996. The
"Seagoing Soarer"? Come on, that's classic. Fun Fact: Wikipedia
describes Voldy as "the most forceful, powerful, and evil" bad guys in
children's literature. This is only because Megatron, Skeletor,
and Mesmeron from the old Pac-Man cartoon are television
characters. Otherwise, Riddle would be serving those guys coffee
and calling them "sir". |
| Fred
And George Weasley Ron's older twin brothers, who dropped out of Hogwarts to go into the joke shop/defense contractor business. I think Fred and George are supposed to be all zany and wacky, but mostly I find them humorless and annoying. Like all identical twins
in literature,
both are
protrayed as the same being, spread out over two bodies, with no
distinctions whatsoever. For this reason,
I refer to them collectively as
"F&G" which incidentally looks a lot like the word
"FAG". This is
unintentional, although I have little doubt that some sick puppy is
writing "twincest" fic about them as I write this, which makes me throw
up in my mouth a little. Fun Fact: Unlike Xamot and Tomax from G.I. Joe, if you beat Fred to death with a crowbar, George won't feel it; you have to hit George, too. |
|
| Remus
Lupin A werewolf spy, currently infiltrating the pro-Voldemort werewolf community. As cool as this might sound, Remus won't be saying anything or doing anything throughout most of the book. Instead, more attention is placed on his romantic tension with yet another C-level castmember. When not baying at the moon or
sneaking into enemy territory, Lupin's a pretty dull guy, which is why
fans have chosen to embellish his life by inferring a gay love affair
with Severus Snape. This is based on sound logic, as it's obvious
from the
subtext of the books that Rowling uses lycanthropy as a euphemism for
homosexuality. For example, Lupin's obviously gay, and he's
depicted as a werewolf, which as we all know is Rowling's metaphor for
homosexuality. Wait, did I say the logic was sound? Becuase
what I mean was "circular". Fun
Fact: A master thief in the tradition of his father and
grandfather before him, Lupin frequently operates with his longtime
accomplices, Daisuke Jigen and Goemon Ishikawa, while evading
the pursuit of the hapless Inspector Zenigata. .... Oh, wait. Wrong guy. |
| Nymphadora
Tonks As Tonks hasn't appeared in the crappy Harry Potter movies yet, I'm forced to resort to crappy fan art for her picture here... or I could just use this picture of Natalie Portman playing a pink-haired stripper in "Closer". Yeah, I think we're doin' that. Tonks' seems to have some kind of security job, either with Hogwarts or the Ministry or Interpol or whatever. It doesn't really matter, because all anyone really cares about is her ability to change her hair color at will. Judging from the fan art on Google, this usually ends up being pink and spiky, like anime hair. Being an anime fan, I find this pretty damn dull. For that matter, anyone in Harry Potter presumably has the same ability, so I'm not seeing why this is so important. In any event, in this book, Tonks has left her hair its original brown color, which is apparently a sign she's all bummed out about not getting to go out with Remus Lupin. Now that I think about it, this is a pretty sexist character. She's a big shot security officer, but all anyone cares about is what color her hair is and whether she can land a man. Fun Fact: Man, Natalie Portman is hot. |
![]() |
![]() |
Mike
Smith, aka The Disappointed Reader Mike's big on
Dragon Ball Z, comic books, wrestling, and Count Dooku
from Star Wars, so no matter how much he rags on your favorite books,
you can rest easy knowing he has no taste whatsoever, and therefore his
opinions aren't really that important. Fun Fact: As natural as that shot might look, I had to cradle a lantern/flashlight between my legs and operate the mouse with my right foot to get my webcam to take the picture. |
| A
Bear Battles Snape in Chapter 20. Fun Fact: Bears don't like surprises. |
|
![]() |
Nude Vegeta One of the many delusions I experience during my reading experience, Vegeta appears to me in a dreamlike haze somewhere in Chapter 20 to inspire me to go on in spire of my pain. I think he's naked because he's dead. I'm not sure. Let's just call it fanservice for the ladies out there, OK? In addition to this encounter, I liked to think Vegeta was with me throughout the book in spirit, kind of like a nude midget guardian angel. This is because reading the book felt a lot like that episode of Dragon Ball Z where he's training in a room at 300x normal gravity, doing one-arm pushups while robots shoot at him. Vegeta also serves as a useful comparison of the esoteric nature of the whole Harry/Hermione vs. Harry/Ginny contoversey that's resolved in Chapter 14. No, really. Fun Fact: It was either him or Nude Christopher Lee, so deal with it. |
| Jim
Smith The prideful prince of Saiyans. His only true loyalty is to himself. Wait... I'm still on Vegeta. Lemme start over. The last of the Autobotodumbass tribes that once lived along he banks of the Wabash River, the noble Jim has journeyed to Teh Intarnets to share his profound and ancient wisdom and insightful commentary with our work-a-day modern world that has forgotten the simple ways of reading Thunderbolts and drinking 900 Diet Dr. Peppers every day. Men respect him, women lust for him, and doctors put bird parts in his hair. Since he hates Harry Potter more than I do, and is even less familiar with it, Jim was a natural choice to guest review Chapter 21 with me when I got sick of doing it. Fun Fact: Sorry, ladies, he's taken. |
![]() |
| Airi
Masaki Tenchi's g randmother in the anime series Tenchi Muyo!, and the inspiration of the Airi Masaki rating scale. When a chapter was good, Airi would give a hearty thumbs-up foreshortened to indicate a job well done (left). When a chapter was bad, Airi would open up a can of bitchslap (not pictured). Despite her youthful appearance, Airi is in fact several centuries old, and thus sensitive concerning comments about her age. Fun Fact: I'd hit it. |
|
Christian
Friedrich Schönbein Fun Fact: In 1845, after using his cotton apron to clean a nitric acid spill in his kitchen, Schönbein placed the cloth near his stove to dry, only for it to explode with a flash of light. Realizing he had inadvertantly produced nitrocellulose (flash paper), Schönbein would go on to refine the process, thus creating a practical means of generating nitrocellulose, used in both gunpowder and photographic film. |
![]() |
Exciting, no? Well,
now that we know who's who, let's get on with the review. There
were links at the top of the page if you didn't feel like scrolling all
the way down for this, but down here you get a list of just what's
doing in each chapter, so you can make an informed decision in case you
want to skip around for something you're looking for.
![]() |
One-Thirtieth
of a Book Report. I lay out the ground rules for the review, and make a little dig at the dedication. And then Tony Blair kicks thing off with a whimper as he hosts Cornelius Fudge's recap of the previous crappy books. |
|
![]() |
Book Report
II: and the Legend continues... Snape's here to remind us that he's still a Bad, Bad Dude, then he pinky-swears with some broad, which is the kind of sissy-mary thing they do on Yugi-Oh! and other anime. Is it any wonder the ladies love him? |
|
![]() |
There's a
Chapter Three Now? (astonished gasp) Thrill as Harry Potter sleeps! Right here the book is daring me to find anything enjoyable about it. |
|
![]() |
Book Report
IV: Citizens On Patrol How does Dumbledore pee? And the awful truth about what goes on in your house when you're not around. |
|
![]() |
It is the
Year Chapter Five... |
|
![]() |
SIX! Now
that I have your attention... Showdown at Daigon Alley! Or.... maybe not. |
|
![]() |
Se7en. A really, really, really boring train ride. On the plus side, Harry gets beat up. You take the good, you take the bad, you take 'em both and there you have the Facts of Life. The Facts of Life. |
|
![]() |
You Eight
the Sandbox? How Could You? Desserts! Academicia! Demerits! Tonks' original hair color! Truly this is a world of magic like none other! In case you couldn't tell, that was supposed to be sarcasm. |
|
![]() |
Cambot, Give
Me Rocket #9! The Half-Blood Prince! Can YOU guess who he REALLY is? Actually, you probably shouldn't think about it too much, because this "mystery" is about the only thing going on in the middle third of the book. |
|
| No Need for
Ten! Seriously, Ten Blows. Revealed at last: The shocking origin of Voldemort! Well, wait, we flashed too far back. Check back in a litte later. He should be born by then... |
||
| OMGWTF!!!1!!eleven! It's tryout time as Captain Potter selects his new team's official beater. Huh-huh, I said "beater". |
||
![]() |
Twelfth
Night. The Katie Bell Incident happens here, which is pretty much all you need to know. Really, even that's just a bump in the road for the whole Draco's Secret Plan plotline, so you can pretty much skip this one. |
|
![]() |
Super
Android 13! OK, here we go. The senses-shattering first meeting between Dumbledore and Kid Voldemort. Actually, this is one of the few really good parts to the book, so I'll let this slide. |
|
![]() |
Book Report
XIV: X-Raided. Harry's stupidest plan yet! ... Or IS it? Plus: You're the Man Now, Dog! |
|
![]() |
The '15. Ron and Hermione argue a lot and hurt each other's feelings. It's kind of like "Moonlighting", only more annoying. |
|
![]() |
Christine
Sixteen. It's Christmas at the Burrow, which for some reason means special guest appearances by Remus Lupin, federal werewolf; Rufus Scrimegour, Minister of Creepy; and some hapless gnome who got turned into a tree-topper. |
|
![]() |
When I was
17, it was a very good
year... My patience with Ron being at an end, I decided to retool the character to better appeal to my demographic. The results were quite enjoyable... |
|
![]() |
Eighteen And
Life. I forget what all happened in this chapter. It was mostly Apparitions lessons, I think, which are about the most boring part of this book. You wouldn't think an author could make teleportation dull, but leave it to Rowling to find a way. |
|
![]() |
It's All
Nineteen, Anyway. Harry and Ron are stuck in the hospital and neither one of them dies. Worst chapter ever, just for that. |
|
![]() |
Book Report
XX: Where It All Begins Again. Anagrams are a pathway to many abilities some would consider... unnatural. |
|
![]() |
Trial of the
Twenty-One I kid you not: Harry actually spends large portions of this chapter staring at a wall. I've built up a tolerance to this kind of stupid crap up to now, but even I needed some help with this one... |
|
![]() |
Love 22. Around Chapter 18, I got sick of the book and decided to skip ahead to here and see if things had picked up at all. Surprisingly, everything that happened in Chapters 19-21 was a total waste of time, and 22 picks up perfectly where 18 leaves off. Rowling sucks. |
|
|
|
23-Skiddoo. Voldemort's master plan reavealed! OK, it's more like Dumbledore speculating as to Voldemort's master plan, but I'll take what I can get. If you ever wanted to learn how to rip apart your own soul, look no further. |
|
![]() |
May Two-Four. So Harry's a few days from an important sortie with D-Dore, the big game is this weekend, and he's this close to hitting it off with the little red-haired girl. So naturally, it's about time for him to screw it all up. Big time. |
|
![]() |
In the Year
Chapter 25, If Man Survives, If Woman Survives... Another chapter that doesn't really go anywhere, but the main thing is that Harry pules like a little girl on the eve of his big hero-type mission. So it's kind of like Superman, only not. |
|
![]() |
Too sikhs. The future of the world depends on the endurance of Dumbledore's kidneys! Well, maybe not, but at least there's zombies on hand to sweeten the pot a little. |
|
![]() |
http://weirdal.0catch.com/txt/27.list.html The Battle of Hogwarts! But we don't get to see it, because our main character is stuck listening to Señor Draco gloat. Fortunately, I was on the scene, so I drew it from memory. No need to thank me, just doing my job. |
|
![]() |
Wenniate OMG SPOILERZ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
|
![]() |
Twenty-Nine
Palms, California Not much happens here, so I bash the guy who reviews movies for CNN.com. It's about here that I realize that there is no climax to the book, save for that fight scene in Chapter 27 that the author deliberately ignored. |
|
![]() |
-30- With Big Al laid to rest and the school year at an end, our hero's thoughts soon turn to revenge, but first he's gotta get his old lady off his back, Spidey-Style. Plus, a touching eulogy for our favorite clichéd mentor figure. |
|