ALL OR NOTHING (2002) ***
Reviewed 10/25/02
After the rather anomalous TOPSY-TURVY, Mike
Leigh returns to the working class Brit material which made him one of the most prominent
filmmakers of the 1990s. Here though, it
feels overly familiar, roughly retreading territory Leigh covered in HIGH HOPES and LIFE
IS SWEET. ALL OR NOTHINGs milieu is
even more impoverished, a landscape of desperate people alienated from one other through
tired routine and menial work. Phil (Timothy
Spall) is a cabbie who deals with life by not dealing with it, having long ago walled
himself off from the constant bickering between his wife and son. Wife Penny (Lesley Manville) works at the
check-out counter at a grocery store, and occasionally goes out with friends like the
funny, dependable Maureen (Ruth Sheen) and her opposite, the alcoholic Carol (Marion
Bailey). Maureens daughter, Donna
(Helen Coker), is in a rough and tumble relationship with her boyfriend, Jason (Daniel
Mays), who has just gotten her pregnant. Carols
promiscuous daughter, Samantha (Sally Hawkins), eyes Jason while dealing with her own
stalker. Phil and Pennys daughter,
Rachel (Alison Garland), works at a retirement home and also deals with an unwanted
approach from an older co-worker. Then
theres her brother, Rory (James Corden), a total layabout who explodes the moment
his mother opens her mouth. As usual, each
actor in a Leigh film invests more in their character than initially meets the eye. They gradually progress from types to individuals
who surprise in their capabilities. The
entire cast is striking, but Manville and Sheen make the greatest impression, two of the
best performances of the year.